Showing posts with label Kevin McCrea. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kevin McCrea. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Cost Per Vote in A-B District 9 Preliminary Election

Incumbent Mark Ciommo yesterday sailed into a first-place win in the preliminary municipal election for Allston-Brighton District 9 City Councilor.

But challenger Alex Selvig outspent him by nearly three-to-one in the cost-per-vote metric. Selvig's expenditure of more than $26 per vote cast for him puts him in the same ballpark as mayoral candidate Michael Flaherty and incumbent Mayor Thomas Menino.

Ciommo took 3,493 votes compared to second-place Selvig's 1,353, third-place Abigail Furey's 784, and fourth-place Benjamin Narodick's 188.

Comparing these vote totals to the money spent by the campaigns as of the last reporting period (through September 4th), the candidates rank differently in the price per vote:
  • Selvig: $26.57 per vote
  • Ciommo: $9.41 per vote
  • Furey: $7.46 per vote
  • Narodick: $2.45 per vote
Of course, none of this money was directly handed to voters in exchange for their votes. The big expenditures were primarily mailings, polling, phone banking, consulting and staffing, get-out-the-vote efforts, and so on.

There were some significant expenditures in the last couple of weeks -- i.e., bulk mailings -- that have not yet been accounted for in the campaign finance reports to date, so this estimate of cost-per-vote will be revised upwards next month upon receipt of the new reports.

The A-B District 9 City Councilor expenditures compare to the city-wide costs of $26, $25, $17, and $4 per vote for mayoral candidates Flaherty, Menino, Sam Yoon, and Kevin McCrea, respectively.


Image of "Day 4 - Paying off debt" by quaziefoto provided through a Creative Commons license.

Sunday, September 20, 2009

No-Shows at Allston-Brighton Day Parade

The Allston-Brighton Day Parade normally occurs one or two weekends before the fall primaries or preliminary municipal election.

Sure, crowd-wise this parade is nothing compared to the St. Patrick's Day Parade in South Boston. But the timing has, in recent years, made it a popular event for political hopefuls to attend a public event and gain publicity before the A-B voters.

This year was no different -- except for a surprising number of no-shows, particularly among the candidates for councilor-at-large.

Little did they know that we in A-B would be taking attendance -- and broadcasting it on the intertubes.

You know, if Mayor Thomas Menino himself thinks a parade important enough to show up, then it is probably important enough for a councilor-at-large wannabe, too.

[right] Mayor Menino, his wife, and state Representative Michael Moran lead the parade ahead of the Boston College Marching Band.


Mayor's Race

In attendance:
  • Thomas Menino, incumbent
  • Michael Flaherty
  • Sam Yoon
No-show:
  • Kevin McCrea
McCrea as a no-show is not too surprising. He's running a gadfly-like insurgency campaign, not following conventional wisdom in his unconventional campaign. His anti-BRA message had the potential to resonate with A-B voters bothered by the issue of institutional expansion, but he doesn't appear to have been spending much time in the district and spent the afternoon at the Allston Village Street Fair and Moran's barbecue.


Allston-Brighton District 9 City Councilor

In attendance:
  • Mark Ciommo, incumbent
  • Abigail Furey
No-shows:
  • Alex Selvig
  • Ben Narodick
Narodick's absence is not surprising, since he is running a very-low expense campaign that probably couldn't afford the parade entrance fee given the Rosh Hashanah holiday season.

But Selvig's absence is very surprising because of family commitments (attending a nephew's birthday). Two years ago he ran the 5-K race and then marched in the parade.


Boston City Councilor-At-Large

In attendance (in order of appearance):
  • Stephen Murphy, incumbent
  • Andrew Kenneally
  • Ayanna Pressley
  • Doug Bennett (no, he does not look like a auto-dialer-machine)
  • Robert Fortes
  • update: John Connolly, incumbent
No-shows:
  • John Connolly, incumbent
  • Ego Ezedi
  • Tomas Gonzalez
  • Tito Jackson
  • Sean Ryan
  • Jean-Claude Sanon
  • Scotland Willis
  • Bill Trabucco
  • Hiep Nguyen
  • Felix Arroyo, Jr.
Most surprising was Connolly's absence as an incumbent in the race. He has been seen periodically in the last two years at community meetings in A-B, so we know that he's not ignoring the district. He has a politically-savvy team, however, and may have calculated that he would get better exposure elsewhere. On the other hand, could Connolly's no-show have something to do with an imminent bundle-of-joy?

Update: Connolly's team tells me that he was, in fact, in the parade. He had no banner, only a small group, was marching out-of-order (nearer the front), and I obviously missed him. Sorry!

Another surprising move is the absence of Nguyen, since A-B has a substantial Asian-American population -- not just Chinese-American, but a growing number of Vietnamese-Americans, too.

The bottom six candidates in cash-in-hand as of the end of August were all among the ten no-shows in the A-B parade. That can't be a coincidence, suggesting that a parade entrance fee (and the effort/expense of organizing people to attend) was considered by many of them to be a poor use of limited resources. But Felix Arroyo, Jr., is wallowing in cash -- and his father attended the parade back in 2007 -- so his absence is hard to explain.

Sunday, September 13, 2009

Hey Globe, Where Have You Been for the Past 16 Years?

The Boston Globe buried a story on page 20 of their paper that is probably the biggest shot of this election campaign: that several of Mayor Thomas Menino's top officials have been deleting all their emails on a daily basis, thereby likely violating state law by destroying those public records.

A quick look through my own email shows nineteen emails either to or from two specific city officials cited in the Globe article -- and a twentieth email on mayoral candidate Kevin McCrea's blog -- that should have been archived during the past two years, but appear not to have been. On the face of it, those are possibly twenty specific violations of the state Public Records Law that each carry a potential penalty of up to $500 and/or one year in prison.

After reading the story, I am left with a jaw-dropping question: Why did it take the Globe 16 years to figure out that Menino's closest adviser was deleting all his electronic records?

I am dumbstruck that the paper of record in Boston does not appear to have requested such electronic public records from Michael Kineavy or Thomas Tinlin during all this time -- or at least realized what was going on when all their public records requests came for naught.

Hey Globe, where have you been all this time?

The Globe deserves some credit, nonetheless, for doing some serious investigative reporting this year leading up to the mayoral election later this month. It is important for residents to know what their city and elected officials have been doing so that they can make an informed choice to re-elect Menino or choose someone else.

The Globe mentions Michael Kineavy, the city's chief of policy and planning, and Thomas Tinlin, the commissioner of the transportation department, as producing zero emails in a request for all emails from a specific time period -- i.e., no incoming or outgoing emails. The Globe story states that the city has admitted the problem, and the corporation counsel, William Sinnott, is in the process of addressing it.

Public records of all kinds must be maintained for a minimum of two years under the state's Public Records Law. While it might appear at first to be difficult to prove that a person has deleted public records -- because the files are, by the nature of the violation, deleted -- there are independent ways to determine if such public records should exist, because other people are on the list of recipients or senders of those emails.

A quick look through my email indicates:
  • Thirteen emails, written by other people, addressed to Tinlin in the time period 7/23/07 - 8/24/08;
  • Two emails written by Tinlin on 8/11/08; and
  • Four emails, written by other people, addressed to Kineavy between 12/14/07 and 5/15/08.
That's 19 specific cases of emails that should have been archived as public records under state law, but appear not to have been; McCrea's letter makes it an even 20. I'm sure that other people around the city can produce their own lists of emails, sent to or received from these two city officials, that ought to be archived by the city as public records. An easy way the Globe could find more such emails would be to submit a public records request, say, to the Boston Redevelopment Authority for all emails written by or received by BRA employees that include Kineavy and/or Tinlin in the To/cc/From header fields.

Left unanswered in the Globe story was the motivation of both Tinlin and Kineavy in systematically deleting these email public records. Were they trying to hide the trail behind controversial (or worse) actions on their part? Until we hear more from them directly to explain their actions, this story will not likely go away.

There is no question that city employees should be saving their emails. An easy way? Move them into folders when you are done reading them in your inbox. That's what most other people do.

As for the Globe? When you finally get a scoop like this, why do you bury it on page 20 of the Sunday paper?


Update: Boston City Councilor-At-Large and mayoral challenger Michael Flaherty has announced that on Monday he will request state Attorney General Martha Coakley and Suffolk County District Attorney Daniel Conley to investigate the allegedly improper or illegal deletion of electronic public records by officials in the Menino administration.

Update 2: Flaherty will be joined by both of the other mayoral challengers, Kevin McCrea and Councilor-At-Large Sam Yoon, in calling for the investigation during a Monday morning press conference.


Image of a paper shredder by Shane Vigil provided through a Creative Commons license.